The Pain Scale Predicament

Ask any person who deals with pain how they feel about the 0-10 pain scale commonly used in doctor's offices and hospitals, and you will likely get a very colorful answer.

And it is also likely that each person you talk to will give a much different answer about how they themselves use the pain scale.

Pain is subjective

Certainly, pain is subjective. And giving a number to your pain, particularly while IN pain and therefore have cloudy thinking, can feel impossible.

Add to that the worry that you are being judged, especially in an ER or urgent care setting, and that based on your answer you may or may not get the relief you need.

The pain scale doesn't work for chronic pain

The pain scale is mired in confusion and indecision. It's no wonder that the chronic pain community has made many of their own (both joking and useful) pain scales and hilarious memes based on this conundrum.

Outside factors can contribute to pain

On a recent drive to the clinic for my CGRP treatment, John and I had a discussion about how what might be a 4 at home in bed with meds available becomes an 8 when you are stuck in a car far from home without medication. Many factors can contribute to basic pain making it harder to deal with, and therefore higher on the pain scale.

My friend Selena Marie Wilson, a poet, artist, and administrator for the Facebook support group “BrainWreck Rebels” is now in a constant state of migraine. She told me “I really don't like the standard pain scale because it simplifies too much.

There's no comparison to other symptoms

As a starting point, it's not bad, but too many doctors don't go into any more depth, such as asking a patient to rank the pain plus the intensity of other symptoms to reach a more accurate idea... mentally, I use a 1-20 scale.” She went on to explain how many extenuating factors and additional symptoms contribute to her pain. “I do think my personal pain scale has changed since becoming daily chronic, because all the new symptoms taught me just how much things you normally wouldn't think contribute to pain actually do.”

The numbers aren't always taken seriously

On the other hand, my spoonie friend Julie, who is struggling with migraines as well as a multitude of other kidney-related and autoimmune ailments including POTS, told me in no uncertain terms (expletives removed):

I hate the pain scale. It should be used only for people with a sore back or broken arm, not for people with chronic illnesses. I never EVER say 10 when I go into the ER... if I go with chest pain, migraine, or ovarian pain, even if I am bawling and hunched over, it's always a 7. I was told once in a hospital that if you say 10 and aren't there with a broken bone they won't take you seriously. Today in the ER? I couldn't move my arm, I was dizzy, and my BP was sky-high but you know what? 7. If it's lower they'll ask why I'm there, higher they'll tell me most people with that number are in tears or can't talk. When I miscarried? 7. When I can't see out of one eye and my BP is 180/130? 7. My 10 is their 20. My 7 is their 15. It's an arbitrary number.

Personalizing the pain scale

As for me, my personal pain scale is still 0-10. For me, 4 is a dividing line.

  • At 4, I have to treat. I will often lie down at that point, usually temporarily.
  • At 6 I try to medicate heavily and go all the way to sleep, maybe still only temporarily.
  • At 7-8 I get into bed all day and rescue medication territory (for me, this means sumatriptan injection and Phenergan suppository).
  • At 9, I am crying, and need assistance, usually john tapping on my head, and I can't lie still but need to rock or constantly shift my head and neck to new positions. Vomiting can come at this time, or sometimes only after days of pain varying from 4 to 10.
  • 10, for me, is not “the worst pain imaginable” in the whole world for any person, like those who are shot in the stomach or have a limb amputated without anesthesia or are giving birth to twins in the woods. It is the worst pain imaginable FOR ME.

My worst migraine attack

The worst migraine (and pain, total, which includes childbirth and pancreatitis) was in May of 2014. I went into the ER screaming and insensible. This was my “cluster-style” migraine and I was put on oxygen. I had to pace, bang my head, and rock back and forth. There was no being still. This is my 10.

I will never say 10 again

I will never say “10” again until I am at that point. I came very close last month, when I told the nurse, “I am approaching my 10” but even though I'd vomited repeatedly (which I only do at 8 to 10) and lost control of my bladder, I still didn't quite get there.

What I say in the emergency room

When I go into the ER, I usually say 8. It has kind of become my fallback the way Julie's is 7. Twice in the last 6 months I've had ER nurses say to me, “And your pain is at a 10?” I was surprised at that assumption and wasn't sure either time whether they just figured (cynically?) I would say 10, or whether my demeanor, blood pressure, and heart rate made them think 10. Both times I said “Um no, actually... I'm at an 8.”

Sometimes at the ER I'm as low as 6, but have been in fluctuating severe pain for as long as a week with no reprieve, so I still say 8, which I think goes along with Selena's additional symptoms and circumstances.

Pain is relative

And, I think of those who have posted in support groups about being at a 10 but heading out to the store, or being at a 10 and still taking care of their kids. I think about people who have never handled much pain at all passing a kidney stone, and what their version of “8” is compared to mine.

And I think about how much of a baby I can be about other pain I've had, like the pain in my hand recently from a twisted nerve, or the back pain from my NSAIDS-induced ulcer before it was diagnosed and treated. I have high pain tolerance, I think, but maybe just regarding head pain; yet, I can lie still for hours and have very sensitive areas like my upper chest tattooed which caused my artist friend (who does the tattooing) to tell me that I am “one tough chick.”

Do doctors know the pain scale is problematic?

Finally, I think that doctors and nurses know that the numerical pain scale is very subjective and problematic, but it's the best method they have for determining the pain their patient is currently feeling. They know that someone's 10 is someone else's 5, and that some people will say 10 all the time while some people never will. They know that some people will try to be as honest as possible and some will say what they think doctors and nurses want to hear.

What are your thoughts on, and experiences with, the numerical pain scale? Feel free to let us know in the comments!

By providing your email address, you are agreeing to our privacy policy.

This article represents the opinions, thoughts, and experiences of the author; none of this content has been paid for by any advertiser. The team does not recommend or endorse any products or treatments discussed herein. Learn more about how we maintain editorial integrity here.

Join the conversation

Please read our rules before commenting.