Hi kacie
It is hard to think of migraines as normal when all I think about is how to get rid of the pain. I suffer from similar head pain. Sometimes I think there are many discreet types of headaches. The headaches that hurt the face I usually consider as nerve pain that start along the top sides of the head in the trigeminal nerve. I have not found it responds to triptans.
To complicate matters, I will have more than one headache at a time and must treat them all to reduce my pain to manageable levels. The numbness and twitching may be part of the nerve response, not sure. I find I get face twitching as a side effect of Tylenol 3.
My doctor sends me for an MRI occasionally to make sure that the various head pains are migraine related and not something else. Getting your first headache so late in life sounds unusual and maybe worth more exploring.
As so much time has passed, I assume your headache has too. Can you share more on how you have been since you last posted? What ended up working for you head pain?